TAKE 5
Friday, December 4, 2009 at 8:36AM 
Haven't yet graduated beyond ripping open the packet of cake mix? Then this is for you! 5 packet mixes/pre made dough's ranging from gourmet to off the supermarket shelf were blind taste tested and reviewed by a panel of eight. This week it's Packet Mix & pre made dough Chocolate Chip Cookies being tested.
The Contenders
1. Aunty Kath's $4.29 Homebake Chocolate chip (Gluten Free)
2. Betty Crocker $5.33 Milk Chocolate Chunk Cookies
3. Donna Hay $14.95 Chocolate Chunk Cookie Mix
4. White Wings $5.32 Choc Chip Cookies (Variety Pack)
5. Aunty Kath's $4.29 Homebaked Chocolate Chip
After a cookie taste mix up, Sarah & David were disqualified this round, but thank you for participating!
Jodie wasn't available, so Daniel took her spot to become the "Mother & Son" team with his Mum Debbie.
Claire makes her first appearance on the panel. Thank you all.
Unmarked boxes of baked cookies were sent to the taste testers along with review forms in order to rate each cookie from one to five, comment on taste and texture plus an overall opinion. After collating the information the results were as follows...
From a possible score of 40
Aunty Kath's GF 18 comments included "OK, but something not right" Mark
"YUK!!" "Disgusting" Emma
Betty Crocker 19.5 comments included "Not enough choc chips" Tim
"Nice texture" "Strange flavour" Claire
Donna Hay 34.5 comments included "This is the best tasting, melts in your mouth" Debbie
"Pretty much exactly what I want in a cookie. Daniel
White Wings 31.5 comments included "Nice choc flavour, loved it!" Jake
"Weird taste" Emma
Aunty Kath's 23.5 comments included "Buttery, ok" Cindy
"Sucked" Mark
Like the Brownie taste test, an easy win for Donna Hay!
Reader Comments